The Hollies The Hollies Greatest Hits 1973 and Hollies Live (Hollies Live Hits in the UK) 1977

Between 1966 and 1974 The Hollies had 6 top 10 singles in the US, and 12 in the top 40 (1966-1983). They were even bigger in the UK, where they had 18 top 10 singles and 29 in the top 40, between 1963 and 1988. As British Invasion groups go, they had a lot going for them. Lead singer Allan Clarke with harmonies from Tony Hicks and Graham Nash made them one of the stronger vocal groups, and the three were also quality songwriters, although they recorded many songs from other writers. The 1973 Greatest Hits contains all of their top 10 US singles except 1974's The Air That I Breathe (which was added to the 2002 reissue). So you get Carrie Anne, Bus Stop, On A Carousel, Long Cool Woman In A Black Dress, He Ain't Heavy, He's My Brother, Just One Look, Pay You Back With Interest, Look Through Any Window, Stop, Stop, Stop, and several more. It is packed with great songs, and spectacular harmony singing. Even when Nash left in 1969 to form CSN, Terry Sylvester was clearly up to the high harmony parts that Nash sang.

Hollies Live 1977 (with a different cover and titled Live Hits in England) is a very well recorded live album that includes several songs from the four years between these records. The Air That I Breathe is here as well as Springsteen's 4th of July, Asbury Park (Sandy), Another Night, I Can't Tell The Bottom From The Top, and I'm Down. There are seven songs that are on both records, so they are not nearly identical, and both have lots to recommend them. The original singles on Greatest Hits are all classics, and include Graham Nash's distinctive, slightly nasal high register that has a certain indisputable magic. But again, Sylvester can also hit all those notes, and the tight ensemble playing and more recent songs on the live set show a band that wasn't yet ready for nostalgia in 1977.

You can't go wrong with either of these. Both are currently available in vinyl and CD versions.