I have an ongoing love/indifference relation ship with Paul McCartney. I think some of his songs are great, and I think much of his music is just OK.
Let me make one thing clear. I'm no Paul denier. First and foremost, if he never wrote a song or played some amazing bass part, he's still worthy of great fame just for his singing. He's a really great singer, right there with, well, anybody. As a bass player he is unique. He played bass with the Beatles like it was another lead instrument, not just foundational. Sure, others have done the same, but there are some McCartney bass lines that it seems no one but he could create. Drive My Car comes to mind, but there are tons of them.
Then there's songwriting, and Paul is a gifted songwriter that leans a bit too far toward the sentimental sometimes. I often think that if he had produced one record every six or seven years, they could have included only his best songs, and every one of them would be untouchable. Of course he'd need a producer to cut the wheat from the chaff, as it were. But if he had done so, his work and reputation would be different from what we have. I haven't listened to some of his records more than once, but again, there's always something there that's darn good.
We don't need to compare him to Lennon, and as circumstances will have it, that's not very fair. But for all of Paul's lesser output, there's Some Time In New York City, the most god-awful dreck released by any ex-Beatle. So Paul made some mistakes along the way. And he made some gems. One of those gems would be Band On The Run, regarded by many as the pinnacle of Paul's solo work. I know there are other opinions, but face it, it's in the top three no matter how you cut it.
And that brings us to the recent Paul McCartney releases, both associated with Band On The Run. The first is Band On The Run (Underdubbed Mixes). As fantastic as Band On The Run is, it may be even better stripped of some of it's, well, production. This is a fun listen, and if you love Band On The Run, you should get to hear it. It reveals a lot about the record in some fun and exciting ways, and it strips the veneer off of a record that apparently didn't require it. It is only available in a 2 CD or 2 LP deluxe Band On The Run, or streaming.
Then there is One Hand Clapping. Basically the soundtrack to a "Let It Be" style video of the band, made shortly after the release of Band On The Run, in studio. The recordings are of McCartney and crew playing recent Wings songs, Beatles hits, oldies, and odd covers. The set is just killer. If anybody thought that Wings were not an actual band, and just Paul's boys, this should set the record straight. There are some twee moments, but not many, and there's a lot of rocking. The recording is very good, clear and clean. Like a live recording without an audience. In fact it sounds like a tour rehearsal much of the time, and that's good.
Chaos and Creation in the Backyard may his his strongest recent work, but these gems from the golden days of Wings are great bonbons for his fans.
Agreed on Chaos And Creation.
ReplyDelete